Just some friction in The Machine |
Thursday, November 20, 2003
Posted
10:00 PM
by Gerald Klaas
Now though, I know that everything I understand is, in fact, an interpretation. That interpretation is influenced by "theory". When theory fails (it happens more than most scientists care to admit), it must be revised so as to explain the "new" result.Later, David Goodyear says Ok, the voices in my head are telling me that any reputation I had before, for knowledge and wisdom, has now been totally demolished. But, that happened with a bunch of mentors also, once I learned the truth.Actually, David, in my book, your reputation for knowledge and wisdom just increased. I'm fond of telling people about the moment in my Advanced Algebra course where I realized that our number system (and all of mathematics) works because we defined it that way. That is, in Advanced Algebra, we learned how we can define new number systems with new operations, identity elements, groups and rings and have it function analogous to what we're all so familiar with. (The base 10 numbers with addition, subtraction, multiplication and division.) People seem to be OK with that observation (maybe it's because they aren't very interested in math). Then I follow with the next observation, which is that *everything* we know is made up. Somewhere, sometime, somebody made it up. It doesn't matter what it is, math, physics, language, it's all made up. We make the rules, we learn to interpret according to the rules that we made up. The next logical step is David's observation, i.e. *everything* we know is an interpretation. What I *know* is only in my head. My interpretations change what I know. So David, the voices in my head tell the voices in your head not to sweat it.
Posted
5:34 PM
by Gerald Klaas
Tuesday, November 18, 2003
Posted
1:25 PM
by Gerald Klaas
Sunday, November 16, 2003
Posted
10:39 PM
by Gerald Klaas
your lack of debts to economic and cultural interest groups provide you with a unique opportunity to deal with, and perhaps even resolve, some of the state's knottiest issuesI couldn't agree more. There are many things that I disagree with Arnold about, as do most people I talk to, but so far, almost everyone I talk with is willing to give him a fair chance to make some changes. I dare say that we aren't sure what changes to make, and we're willing to accept about anything he wants to try, as long as he is unlike Davis and at least attempts something.
|
Gerald Klaas
I'm trying to follow the ideals of Henry David Thoreau, in his essay On Civil Disobedience. Thoreau refused to cooperate with The Machine of oppressive government and encouraged all moral people to do the same. He referred to this "civil disobedience" as creating friction in the machine. Given enough friction for a long enough period of time, the machine will break.
Courses I teach at the local Community College
|